Hailee Steinfeld and her boyfriend, Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen, brought the magic of the circus to New York with their extravagant Halloween bash.

The couple transformed the event into a big-top spectacle, captivating guests with their creative and coordinated ringmaster costumes.

Although Hailee Steinfeld and Josh Allen—who have been dating since spring 2023—didn’t share any photos from the Halloween party on their own Instagram accounts, Allen’s teammates and their significant others gave fans a glimpse inside the circus-themed bash.

Hailee Steinfeld And Josh Allen Rule The Ring At Buffalo Bills Halloween Bash

As a dedicated host, Allen kept the energy high, handing out prizes to guests throughout the night, making sure everyone enjoyed the circus-inspired festivities.

A sign inside the venue read, “Welcome to Josh & Hailee’s Circus Showdown,” setting the tone for the night, according to social media posts. Guests entered the event through the mouth of a giant clown, adding a touch of whimsy and drama right from the start.

Hailee Steinfeld Makes Grand Entrance

The Halloween party embraced the full circus theme with immersive decor and classic carnival touches.

Tables were adorned with black and white striped tablecloths, while colorful balloons filled the space, and red-and-white fabric draped from the ceiling, evoking the iconic “big top” of a circus tent. Adding to the festive ambiance, retro clown figures were displayed throughout the venue, giving guests a nostalgic taste of circus history.

Steinfeld, known for her flair on and off screen, dazzled in a classic ringmaster outfit, complete with a red coat and bold detailing, capturing the spotlight in true circus style.

Josh Allen Hosts Circus-Themed Halloween Party

Allen matched his girlfriend’s look with his own ringmaster attire: a red coat accented with gold trim around the collar, layered over a red vest and crisp white shirt, paired with black pants and a signature black top hat.

Circus games kept the crowd entertained, and in one clip, Allen awarded his teammate Shane Buechele a prize for winning one of the fair-inspired games.

Shane, dressed as Travis Barker, enjoyed several games alongside his wife Paige Buechele, who went as Kourtney Kardashian, recreating the memorable concert moment when Kardashian announced her pregnancy. As his prize, Shane took home a Malbon golf bag and a set of custom clubs, reportedly part of a silent auction.

Hailee Steinfeld And Josh Allen Go All Out With Circus-Themed Menu

Danika Johnson, wife of Bills defensive lineman Austin Johnson, shared glimpses of the party on her Instagram Stories, revealing playful details like popcorn boxes filled with cotton candy and rainbow lollipops at each table.

Steinfeld and Allen went all out with a custom circus-themed menu, featuring creatively named cocktails such as the “Freakshow Fizz” and “Ringleader’s Remedy.”

For non-drinkers, the “Big Top Breeze” offered a non-alcoholic option, while cocktail lovers could choose the “Trapeze Twist,” a gin-based drink, or the vodka-infused “Midnight Acrobat.” Teddy bears and classic fairground toys were suspended from booths and scattered throughout the venue, adding to the authentic circus atmosphere that guests enjoyed.

Hailee Steinfeld Becomes Part Of Bills Mafia

The couple kept their relationship under wraps for months until Steinfeld was seen supporting Allen at his game in London in October 2023. It wasn’t until July, however, that Allen officially “hard launched” their relationship by sharing a photo of the “Hawkeye” star alongside his inner circle during a summer gathering.

Steinfeld has since become a staple at the Bills games and has shown she’s a true Bills Mafia supporter.

“Football season is back which means a few things. A) I get to watch my favorite person continue to make NFL history every week (go off 17),” she said as party of her September issue of her “Beau Society” newsletter, per Us Weekly. “B) We’re just a few weeks away from drastic temperature drops (California girl speaking) where you’ll find me drinking hot chocolate bundled in vintage Bills gear.”

The actress added, “I spent most of the game thinking about how lucky I am to get a front-row seat to the magic that is JA17, the entire Bills team and the stadium energy. The people who make up Bills Mafia are second to none.”